Friday, April 20, 2007

John Allen on the Motu Proprio and a short comment on the question of tolerance

By way of John Allen of NCR: Hold your breath for the next media frenzy: The Latin Mass document is coming

"The last sentence of [Cardinal Walter] Kasper's letter [to the International Council of Christians and Jews], the text of which I have, is the key line: "While I do not know what the pope intends to state in his final text [of the Motu Proprio], it is clear that the decision that has been made cannot now be changed."

"Kasper's language clearly indicates that something definitive has happened. It adds to the confirmation given by the Vatican's Secretary of State, Cardinal Tarcisio Bertone, on March 31 that a motu proprio from Benedict XVI, meaning a document under the pope's personal authority, on the pre-Vatican II Mass is coming.

"Catholic publishers in Rome, anticipating the pope's decision, have already begun preparing new editions of the pre-Vatican II Mass books, called the "1962 Missal" because that was the last year prior to the Second Vatican Council (1962-65) in which an official liturgical book according to the old rite was issued."


The above text speaks for itself.

Another part of this article focuses on the concern of some with regard to the classical Missal, and also about a general theological worldview they see as being pre-conciliar (ie. now no longer). Ultimately, the issue is cast in the light of concern for intolerance, though I would propose that as a "sed contra" to this, what needs to be looked at is the issue of syncretism and relativism to thereby better understand wherein lie the differences between tolerance and intolerance truly understood.

Tolerance today is often taken precisely to mean syncretism and relativism. As such, praying for conversion is understood as being intolerant by many. But genuine tolerance permits disagreement; it permits one to believe this or that to be misguided, wrong, or at least not fully in accord with the whole truth; conversely it allows for the belief of something to be true. This is a crucial distinction.

This may be a good time to pull out the fully contextualized teaching of the Church on these questions, as well as Ratzinger's book Truth and Tolerance. One must likewise consider the call of Christ and the Gospel, and distinguish the difference between a change in mission and the Christian call to evangelization, as opposed to shifts in methodology.

Finally, as regards liturgical language, I would highlight that we must take careful consideration of the difference between hate speech or even polemical language from biblical, metaphorical language.

More recent articles:


Catholic Education Foundation Seminar 2025: The Role of the Priest in Today’s Catholic School
July 16-18, at the Athenaeum of Ohio (the seminary of the Archdiocese of Cincinnati).Fr Peter Stravinskas of the Catholic Education Foundation is once again offering this excellent three-day seminar, intended primarily for bishops, priests, and seminarians. It is entitled The Role of the Priest in Today’s Catholic School.For further information: c...

Pope Francis RIP
Deus, qui inter summos sacerdótes fámulum tuum Franciscum ineffábili tua dispositióne connumerári voluisti: praesta, quáesumus; ut, qui Unigéniti Filii tui vices in terris gerébat, sanctórum tuórum Pontíficum consortio perpétuo aggregétur. Per eundem Christum, Dóminum nostrum. Amen.Courtesy of Shawn Tribe and Liturgical Arts JournalGod, Who in Thy ...

The Byzantine Paschal Hour
In the Roman Rite, the minor Hours of Easter and its octave are celebrated according to a very simple and archaic form, which consists solely of the psalmody, the antiphon Haec dies, and the prayer, with the usual introduction and conclusion. (Haec dies is labeled as an “antiphon” in the Breviary, but it is identical to the first part of the gradu...

Easter Sunday 2025
An icon of the Harrowing of Hell made in Constantinople in the late 14th century.Let all partake of the feast of faith. Let all receive the riches of goodness. Let no one lament their poverty, for the universal kingdom has been revealed. Let no one mourn their transgressions, for pardon has dawned from the grave. Let no one fear death, for the Savi...

The Twentieth Anniversary of Pope Benedict XVI’s Election
On this Holy Saturday, we also mark the 20th anniversary of the election of His Holiness Pope Benedict XVI. Let us remember with gratitude the gift of his papacy, his graciousness and good humor, his many wise and well-considered writings, his paternal love especially for priests and religious, but of course above all, his restoration to the Church...

Holy Saturday 2025
The Harrowing of Hell, by Duccio di Buoninsenga, 1308-11 R. Recessit pastor noster, fons aquae vivae, ad cujus transitum sol obscuratus est; * nam et ille captus est, qui captivum tenebat primum hominem: hodie portas mortis et seras pariter Salvator noster disrupit. V. Destruxit quidem claustra inferni, et subvertit potentias diaboli. Nam et ill...

Good Friday 2025
The table of the Epitaphios at the end of Vespers today at St Anthony the Abbot, the Russian Greek-Catholic church in Rome.For how shall we be able to know, I and thy people, that we have found grace in thy sight, unless thou walk with us, that we may be glorified by all people that dwell upon the earth? And the Lord said to Moses: This word also, ...

Desacralizing Lent
Christ in the Desert, 1898, by Breton RivièreI have been enjoying Peter Kwasniewski’s new book Close the Workshop, which argues that the old rite did not need to be fixed and that the new rite cannot be fixed. To support his argument, Kwasniewski begins with an analysis of the Second Vatican Council’s Constitution on the Liturgy, Sacrosanctum Conci...

Holy Thursday 2025
Thou, o Lord, didst command us to be partakers of Thy Son, sharers of Thy kingdom, dwellers in Paradise, companions of the Angels; ever provided we keep the sacraments of the heavenly host with pure and undefiled faith. And what may we not hope of Thy mercy, we who received so great a gift, that we might merit to offer Thee such a Victim, namely, t...

The Chrism Mass: Tradition, Reform and Change (Part 2) - Guest Article by Abbé Jean-Pierre Herman
This is the second part of an article by Fr Jean-Pierre Herman on the blessing of oils, which is traditionally celebrated at the Mass of the Lord’s Supper, and the recent reforms thereof; the first part was published on Tuesday. The French original was published on Sunday on the website of the Schola Sainte-Cécile as a single article. Fr Herma...

For more articles, see the NLM archives: